The recent announcement that the U.S. has lost its measles elimination status means that the disease is once again circulating consistently for over a year in our country, and with it, paralytic polio, congenital rubella, and other vaccine-preventable diseases may return as well.
Having served as Philadelphia’s Health Commissioner during a measles outbreak in 2023-2024, I am both horrified and not surprised. Misinformation and deep fear around vaccination go back for as long as human beings have attempted immunization. There is something about injecting substances, however well-studied, into the body that makes many people afraid, and that fear sometimes causes us to act in ways that seem irrational and that can go against our best interests, a tendency that has only accelerated since the pandemic.
That fear is the reason that the willingness of politicians and their appointees to spread lies about vaccines is so devastating. When I sit in exam rooms these days with my patients and talk about getting flu shots, about vaccinating their children against measles, mumps, and rubella, or even about the birth dose of vitamin K, which prevents catastrophic bleeding in newborns, I hear the echoes of those lies, amplifying their natural parental concerns.
Those falsehoods have now led to more illnesses and deaths by stoking Pennsylvania’s measles epidemic, the nation’s largest, with over 1,500 cases and six deaths reported.
Expect more to come. The decision by North American health officials to strip the U.S. of its measles-free designation marks a huge step backwards.
Robert F. Kennedy Jr. has led the spewing of misinformation about vaccines and has filled our nation’s Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP) with people whose only qualification appears to be their willingness to agree with him. But he has not done this alone. We have watched many of our politicians, including physicians, show again and again that they are unwilling to stand up for science.
Exacerbating the outbreak
But there is another factor that helps to amplify fear of vaccines. For many Americans, our health system feels like more an adversary than a trusted support. While the Affordable Care Act helped expand insurance coverage, it did not do enough to control rising health costs, and many Americans face skyrocketing bills. Access to primary care appointments has also declined, as our country continues its pattern of underinvesting in this crucial sector. This lack of access means that many people cannot get care when they need it, or face long waits in emergency rooms rather than seeing a primary care provider whom they know and trust.
There will always be some fear around vaccinations, as there has been since the first vaccines were invented. But there are steps we can take now to help address those fears rather than allowing them to spiral out of control.
Insurance rates are falling, even among children, and those numbers will worsen further with the upcoming cuts to Medicaid. Even for groups, including children, who are exempt from the new Medicaid work requirements, we will see more coverage losses if we don’t invest in more caseworkers and support staff.
And many immigrant families are now afraid to seek care, worried that ICE agents will snatch away their parents or that new “public charge” rules will force them to leave the country if they are likely to use public benefits.
There will always be some fear around vaccinations, as there has been since the first vaccines were invented. But there are steps we can take now to help address those fears rather than allowing them to spiral out of control.
How to stop measles
Our elected representatives need to commit to a new process for the selection of health agency leaders that requires legitimate scientific credentials and nonpartisan review. Our nation’s academic and medical institutions have offered a possible model during the current crisis, coming together to create consensus guidelines on vaccines for the nation since those put out by the CDC are sadly no longer trustworthy. Our leaders also need to address the crisis our nation faces in access to care, both in terms of expanding health insurance coverage and investing in primary care.
We need paid sick time so that parents can take their children to the doctor, so that they can ask their questions and get the answers they need. And those of us who work in health care and public health need to make sure we are not stigmatizing people for their fears, but meeting them where they are, answering their questions, providing care where and when it is needed, and advocating for access to care for all.
We need to make sure that we are earning the trust that we are asking people to give us. Anything less will lead to more outbreaks, more needless suffering, and sadly more deaths. We can and must do better.
Dr. Cheryl Bettigole is a Professor of Clinical Family Medicine & Community Health at the University of Pennsylvania, the Executive Director of Penn’s Center for Public Health, and a Senior Fellow of the Leonard David Institute of Health Economics.
This commentary represents the opinions of the writer and does not represent the University of Pennsylvania.
The Citizen welcomes guest commentary from community members who represent that it is their own work and their own opinion based on true facts that they know firsthand.
MORE ON AMERICAN HEALTHCARE