Do Something

Join us at our next event

The African American Chamber of Commerce of PA, NJ & DE 2023 National Convening of Black Mayors kicks off tonight, Tuesday, May 23 at 5pm with a live, interactive taping of The Citizen’s celebrated podcast, How to Really Run a City: Two Legendary Former Mayors on Getting Sh*t Done at the African-American Museum. Get your tickets here!

Connect WITH OUR SOCIAL ACTION TEAM



Read More

Solutions for curbing gun violence

Listen to the 2021 Citizen podcast series on the surge in gun violence, Philly Under Fire.

Learn more here about Cure Violence, a broad community approach to preventing and reducing gang violence that treats violence as an infectious disease.

The Roca Impact Institute is offering communities and institutions that are committed to ending gun violence a coaching program to learn their CBT-based approach to violence intervention. You can learn more and support their work here.

Drexel University’s Center for Nonviolence and Social Justice operates Helping Hurt People in Philadelphia for survivors and witnesses to violence, from ages 8 to 35. Read more about the program and support them here.

State Senator Art Haywood, representing parts of northwestern Philly and eastern Montgomery County, has demanded Mayor Kenney take action on proposals other communities have used to curb gun violence. You can read these proposals, watch the April 2022 webinar on reducing violence, view proposed legislation, and sign up as an advocate for gun violence prevention on the Senator’s official website.

Read the proposal from former City Controller Rebecca Rhynhart and Councilmember Jamie Gauthier delivered to Mayor Kenney in 2021 on place-based strategies to reduce crime.

The CDC offers a comprehensive resource guide to preventing youth violence by addressing risk factors from the individual level to societal levels.

Be a better Philadelphia Citizen

Here's how

One of the founding tenets of The Philadelphia Citizen is to get people the resources they need to become better, more engaged citizens of their city.

We hope to do that in our Good Citizenship Toolkit, which includes a host of ways to get involved in Philadelphia—whether you want to contact your City Councilmember about stemming the rising tide of gun violence, get those experiencing homelessness the goods they need, or simply go out to dinner somewhere where you know your money is going toward a greater good.

Find an issue that’s important to you in the list below, and get started on your journey of A-plus citizenship.

Vote and strengthen democracy

Stand up for marginalized communities

Create a cleaner, greener Philadelphia

Help our local youth and schools succeed

Support local businesses

Is Social Media Behind Philly’s Rise in Violent Crime?

Instagram feuds, Twitter taunts and online videos are taking the blame for several shootings over the last couple of years. The answer is old-fashioned communication

Is Social Media Behind Philly’s Rise in Violent Crime?

Instagram feuds, Twitter taunts and online videos are taking the blame for several shootings over the last couple of years. The answer is old-fashioned communication

In a city that, for the past two years, has faced historically high numbers of homicides and shootings, it is often difficult to grasp how different factors contribute to the spike in crime in Philadelphia. And among the gruesome headlines and daily reports of violence, one emerging trend has made it particularly challenging to understand: that many shootings appear to have been provoked or exacerbated by disputes over social media.

The murders of Jarell Jackson and Shahjahan McCaskill are just one such case. In October 2020, gang members gunned down the two lifelong friends in a drive-by shooting just outside Jackson’s mother’s house. An investigation by the Inquirer found the shooting took place “over an Instagram feud” between rival gangs that neither were involved in.

That rationale wasn’t uncommon. In March 2021, a WHYY report noted police believed a series of shootings between 2018 and 2019 “to be the result of a handful of rival groups feuding with one another over insults hurled back-and-forth online.”

“We have video, we might have cell phone data, we may have DNA, we may have ballistics, and there’s always some social media that connects to all those things that helps put the case together,” says Frank Vanore.

“It’s part of the crime scene, it’s part of the evidence,” says Frank Vanore, deputy commissioner of investigations in the Philadelphia Police Department.

Vanore says that these kinds of incidents happen “every day,” and that feuds escalating over social media platforms like Instagram, Facebook and even YouTube have contributed to the recent uptick in shootings. While he can’t pinpoint a specific date when the PPD began to take notice of the phenomenon, he says that it dates back several years.

“We have video, we might have cell phone data, we may have DNA, we may have ballistics, and there’s always some social media that connects to all those things that helps put the case together,” he says.

A ‘serious factor’ in escalating conflict

The relationship between social media and real-world violence is complicated and difficult to prove definitively.

For the last 10 years, Dr. Desmond Patton has studied social media and its relationship with offline violence, primarily in Chicago. He has worked with computer scientists to develop algorithms that can detect “psychosocial codes” such as aggression, grief, loss and substance abuse on social media, particularly on Twitter, and believes that “AI and social media can be a better diagnostic tool for better understanding root causes of community-based violence.”

“We do have lots of observational and anecdotal evidence from outreach folks and violence interruption workers … that are concerned and are raising alarms around the amplification of violence through social media,” Patton, director of the SAFELab research initiative at Penn, says. While he can’t say for sure if social media is a “trigger” for violence, what he has heard from workers in the field is enough to raise alarms.

Patton coined the phrase “internet banging,” referring to the way that gangs and their members trade insults and issue challenges to each other’s reputations, which through escalation can result in real-life violence and homicide — even for those who were never involved in the beef to begin with, as with Jackson and McCaskill.

“They’re just putting it on public display,” says Mazzie Casher, “I feel like [it] forces people’s hand to respond, because if your total self-worth is invested in your profile, or your appearance online, then it’s going to be necessary that you respond or retaliate.”

Another way that social media posts can escalate to violence, Patton explains, is the way that individuals express grief about violence in their neighborhoods on platforms like Twitter. Negative responses to those expressions of grief on social media can trigger aggressive backlash, according to his research on the social media presence of deceased Chicago gang member Gakirah Barnes. Barnes participated in “internet banging” — vowing revenge for the death of her friend — just days before she herself was killed in a shooting in 2014.

Mazzie Casher, who co-founded the Philadelphia anti-violence initiative Philly Truce in 2021, describes social media — and Instagram particularly — as an “amplifier” for conflict. “[I mean] they’re just putting it on public display,” he says. “I feel like [it] forces people’s hand to respond, because if your total self-worth is invested in your profile, or your appearance online, then it’s going to be necessary that you respond or retaliate.”

Conflicts on social media don’t only take the form of Tweets, posts and direct messages. Beefs manifest as music videos published on YouTube, as well. According to Vanore, rap groups will often make disparaging songs about their enemies, and these antagonistic videos can at times spark violent confrontations.

“There’s a lot of them out there … I don’t know if they’re receiving money for some of the videos or not, if it’s lucrative or they’re just doing it to do it,” Vanore says. “But we’ve had video shoots … that would turn into a gun violence incident, where they’re filming and next thing you know there’s a shooting going on.”

Little data to back up causal connection

Some experts are not quite convinced about the link between social media and violence. Forrest Stuart, a professor of sociology at Stanford University, says that there just isn’t enough information to make definitive claims one way or another. “I find that I am increasingly an unexciting person to talk to about this stuff, precisely because I feel like my response to this stuff is a lot more measured than people want it to be,” he jokes in an interview.

Stuart has spent thousands of hours interviewing dozens of gang members and gang-associated youth, like Patton focusing his fieldwork in Chicago’s South Side. In some cases, he sat down with shooters immediately following an incident and asked them, what did social media have to do with this? In 2020, he published a book about his research and findings, Ballad of the Bullet: Gangs, Drill Music, and the Power of Online Infamy.

There are many confounding factors to take into account. For instance, low clearance rates for shootings and homicides — that is, the percentage of these cases solved by the police — limits what is known about those incidents: in Chicago, Stuart says, “we’ve seen shooting clearance rates below 10 percent, sometimes as low as 5 percent … We have so much missing data. We have 95 shootings out of 100 where we don’t know not just who it was, but why they did the shooting. Was it related to social media? And were social media and posts actually the catalyst for the shooting?”

“We have 95 shootings out of 100 where we don’t know not just who it was, but why they did the shooting. Was it related to social media?” — Forrest Stuart

There are so many different variables that play into what causes a shooting or violent incident, and so little of that data has been collected, that Stuart believes establishing a causal connection between social media and violence is impossible at this point.

“It’s this huge catalog of on-the-ground factors that we would have to collect, all those for tens of thousands of shootings, in order to be able to model this thing.” Stuart said. “But we’re just light years away from that.”

What we do know is that social media has assimilated into the long list of factors associated with violent crime, as we can see in academic literature and books like Ballad of the Bullet, in headlines about innocent bystanders caught in the crossfire and testimonies of anti-violence activists.

So what can be done about it?

The PPD already has an intelligence bureau dedicated to monitoring social media, keeping tabs on the public accounts of individuals and groups at risk of being involved in violent incidents, acquiring warrants to preserve posts that may connect people to crimes, and taking preventative measures when possible. Vanore believes that tracking the “footprints” of victims of violent incidents and potential suspects — for example, posting photos with firearms — has had the most impact on investigations. Acting proactively on social media, he says, prevents shootings.

Social media beefs can be squashed through conflict mediation services offered by organizations such as Philly Truce. Recent efforts by Casher and Philly Truce’s other co-founder, Steve Pickens, have focused on children in middle school, but social media beefs in school can still lead to physical fights or even threats of gang violence. The effectiveness of these efforts can vary on a case-by-case basis, but according to Casher, “getting them face-to-face is really the trick of the whole thing.”

Another pathway to dampen feuds on social media is education, such as digital literacy courses in K-12 schools. “This is a time when a lot of young people are being introduced to social media, and yet we don’t have clear education around how one might become a thriving and healthy digital citizen,” Patton says.

“We just assume that people know what it means to be online, and yet we have lots of evidence that suggests that a lot of us, regardless of age, don’t really know how to behave on social media platforms,” he continues. “There needs to be increased investment in training a variety of folks — mental health practitioners and physicians and educators — about ethical uses of social media for transformational justice in this space.”

“Getting them face-to-face is really the trick of the whole thing.” — Mazzie Casher

For Stuart, gearing anti-violence community organizations to the digital space is a valuable way to address social media-driven gang violence. One group he has worked with closely, the Institute for Non-Violence Chicago, intervenes in potential conflicts by sending out individuals who grew up in or are familiar with the communities where conflicts are taking place to talk to those involved.

“Now that they’ve got a foothold in neighborhoods, some of their younger violence interrupters who are a little more social media savvy are beginning to ‘friend’ and follow and [monitor daily] the young folks in the neighborhood,” Stuart explains.

There is evidence to indicate that these kinds of programs are helpful in mitigating violence. The Institute for Non-Violence Chicago claims it was able to conduct 300 mediations that “likely prevented a shooting.” PhillyTruce, while a much smaller operation, says that Casher and Pickens have been able to conduct 25 mediations so far, five of which “de-escalated without further incident.”

The two PhillyTruce co-founders recently expanded their services with the introduction of the Safe City Boys program, which held its inaugural Safe City Summit on May 8. The program gears itself toward boys aged 11-15, training them in conflict resolution and financial literacy, as well as teaching creative arts, civics and tools for employment, and will take place every Monday until June 12.

MORE SOLUTIONS TO RISING CRIME

 

Photo by Laura Rivera on Unsplash

The Philadelphia Citizen will only publish thoughtful, civil comments. If your post is offensive, not only will we not publish it, we'll laugh at you while hitting delete.

Support Your Local Journalism. "With your help, we can be the antidote to the failures of big media, the bitterness of national politics, your post-election malaise and the confusion about what to do now" - Roxanne Patel Shepelavy, Executive Director, The Philadelphia Citizen. Button that says Give that leads to a donation page for end of year fundraising. Your gift will fund independent, local journalism and solutions for Philadelphia.

Be a Citizen Editor

Suggest a Story

Advertising Terms

We do not accept political ads, issue advocacy ads, ads containing expletives, ads featuring photos of children without documented right of use, ads paid for by PACs, and other content deemed to be partisan or misaligned with our mission. The Philadelphia Citizen is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit, nonpartisan organization and all affiliate content will be nonpartisan in nature. Advertisements are approved fully at The Citizen's discretion. Advertisements and sponsorships have different tax-deductible eligibility. For questions or clarification on these conditions, please contact Director of Sales & Philanthropy Kristin Long at [email protected] or call (609)-602-0145.