NEWSLETTER SIGNUP

By signing up to our newsletter, you agree to our terms.

Do Something

Pitch Philly to Amazon

Do you agree that Philadelphia would be the perfect location for Amazon’s new headquarters? Pitch your reasons why or why not. Send them to us via Twitter, below in the comments or you can email us at info@thephiladelphiacitizen.org. We’ll share our favorites via social media.

Connect WITH OUR SOCIAL ACTION TEAM



Video

Mayor Kenney's pitch to Amazon on Bloomberg

The Amazon Follies

Is the Kenney administration creative enough to make the sale?

Is the Kenney administration creative enough to make the sale?

“When all think alike, then no one is thinking.”

—Walter Lippman

I’ve been thinking a lot about ol’ Wally’s observation ever since our city government embarked on the much-ballyhooed pitch to bring Amazon’s second headquarters to Philly. Winning the reality TV-like sweepstakes would no doubt be a game-changer for our city and region, and not just for its addition of 50,000 jobs to the local economy; the psychic benefits of becoming Amazon’s second home might be just as crucial. Perhaps it would be the final piece we need to get our swagger back, to once and for all bury the last vestiges of Negadelphia.

But, in the last week or two, the whispers have grown louder: Are our elected leaders—so accustomed to playing small ball, so wedded to incrementalism—up to making the bold case demanded of a moonshot moment?

The first red flag came when it was reported that Harold Epps, the city’s Commerce Director, and John Grady, President of PIDC, the city’s public-private economic development corporation, would lead the effort to win the Amazon windfall, with help from Select Greater Philadelphia, the region’s business attraction nonprofit. This isn’t a knock on Epps, Grady or Select’s Matt Cabrey; they’re all highly competent, and local patriots.

This story made possible by our members.
Become a member today

But is this just the recruitment of a company to our region, or is it something more akin to public spectacle, something that requires an approach that deviates from business as usual, and that differentiates us from the way all other cities may respond to Amazon’s challenge?

The latter is how Pittsburgh seems to see it. Steel city stakeholders—city government, foundations, nonprofits—immediately ponied up $248,000 to hire Maya Design, which is owned by the prestigious Boston Consulting Group, to honcho the city’s bid. Maya helped Pittsburgh apply for—and almost win—a $50 million Smart City Challenge transportation grant last year. The face of their bid will be a team of executives and civic leaders.

Now, given the conditions laid out in the RFP, it seems clear that we stand a better chance on the merits than does our western rival. But shouldn’t we match their boldness in our approach? Instead of governmental paper pushers, shouldn’t the faces of our bid be, I don’t know, Penn President Amy Gutmann? Startup pied piper Bob Moul? Comcast’s Brian Roberts? (There’s been some media speculation that Comcast doesn’t want Amazon invading its turf; I don’t buy it. Surely the town is big enough for both, no?)

You like turnarounds, Jeff Bezos? (See Post, Washington.) How’d you like to be the guy who brings back the city that gave birth to American Democracy, and in the process strikes a blow for the transformative effect of business?

Instead, it seems the city’s approach is decidedly top down. An email went out earlier this week to many of the city’s bold-face name innovators and entrepreneurs from Lauren Cox, the Commerce Department’s Manager of Communications and Press Relations. “As leaders of the Philadelphia tech community, each of you will play an important role as we develop a proposal and pitch our city as the home for Amazon’s HQ2…” she wrote. “…I will be your main point of contact for all things Amazon.”

Cox goes on to ask recipients to “contribute some ‘big ideas’ that could potentially be incorporated into the comms plans and/or proposal,” before asking: “Do you think we should involve drones?”

The entrepreneur who forwarded me this communique had this to say: “You have the city controlling this, as opposed to the city saying, ‘This isn’t what we do. Let’s hire the best that does this and say to them, What do you need?’” He contrasted our approach with Pittsburgh’s: “They said to themselves, ‘We think we have the ingredients to be a global city. Let’s hire the Boston Consulting Group to help us craft that story.’”

But it goes even deeper than that. It’s not just about who is making the pitch—it’s also about what that pitch is. Remember Wally Lippman’s advice, uttered some 50 years before Steve Jobs implored us to Think Different. Here’s where you wish the Kenney administration would set itself apart from every other city in the Amazon competition by thinking more creatively.

Every city seeking the Amazon nod will try and sell Jeff Bezos on an array of inducements targeted to his bottom line. An orgy of tax breaks will be thrown his way. As will a list of attractive demographic and cultural amenities, as Drexel President and Chamber Chairman John Fry so ably laid out in an Inquirer op-ed.

How about this: Let’s stipulate that we’ll match all the inducements others are sending Amazon’s way, but that the heart of our pitch isn’t what we can do for you, Amazon. It’s what you can do for us.

You like turnarounds, Jeff Bezos? (See Post, Washington.) How’d you like to be the guy who brings back the city that gave birth to American Democracy, and in the process strikes a blow for the transformative effect of business? In the New York Times, Ross Douthat argued in favor of an Amazon Detroit:

“The political backdrop, the growing suspicion on right and left about whether big tech serves the common good, raises an interesting question: What if Amazon treated their headquartering decision as an act of corporate citizenship, part public relations stunt and part genuinely patriotic gesture?” Douthat writes. “What if it approached the decision as an opportunity to push back against trends driving populist suspicion of big business…the sense that the New Economy creates wealth but not jobs and that its tycoons are loyal to globalization rather than their country?”

“You have the city controlling this, as opposed to the city saying, ‘This isn’t what we do. Let’s hire the best that does this and say to them, ‘What do you need?’” says one local entrepreneur.

Douthat is right on the argument, but wrong on the city choice. Detroit already has Dan Gilbert leading its charge of reinvention. But why not say to Bezos: How’d you like to be our Dan Gilbert?

Look, we’re already the center of social impact entrepreneurship, even if the city, still wedded to Ben Franklin and cheesesteaks, doesn’t market ourselves that way. Philly invented the B Corp revolution thanks to the nonprofit B Lab —whose local founders, Jay Coen-Gilbert and Bart Houlahan, should be in on the pitch. What if our presentation to Amazon wasn’t a sales pitch, per se, but an invitation to come here and fuel a new American Revolution? One built around the transformative effects of conscious capitalism?

Hell, we could say, we’ll throw tax breaks your way like all the other cities, but we’re also asking something big of you, something bigger than your bottom line: Come here and help fix our schools. Maybe that involves donating to them, or adopting them, or mentoring at-risk youth. But providing jobs isn’t enough. We’re responding to your challenge, Amazon, by challenging you:  Come here and make all of us better.

Now that would be some different thinking.

Header Photo: Jason Redmond

The Philadelphia Citizen will only publish thoughtful, civil posts. We want to be a communal space. But that doesn’t mean you have a First Amendment right to be an idiot. Send us an insulting, offensive and/or wildly off-topic comment and not only will we refrain from posting it -- we will laugh at you before we hit delete.

Recent Tweets
@THEPHILACITIZEN

@thephilacitizen @@thephilacitizen
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
Don't miss The Citizen's own Syra Ortiz-Blanes on @onwurd 's Reality Check with @ellisonreport tonight at 6pm.… https://t.co/gDHtWet4xr 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
Don't miss The Citizen's own Syra Ortiz-Blanes on @onwurd's Reality Check with @ellisonreport tonight at 6pm.… https://t.co/gZNreXDLLm 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
Make the new CitizenCast a part of your evening commute. This week, we call #TimesUp on accused sexual harasser and… https://t.co/hOIMAtm4tY 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
Black history is U.S. history. @NBA legend Charles Barkley highlights a month's worth of Philadelphia's African Am… https://t.co/2EYZKNNE0W 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
RT @RealJabariJones:Really excited that my op-ed in @thephilacitizen made it on @PhillyInquirer morning newsletter's What We're Reading… https://t.co/PH0vcMRrMe 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
Philly’s on the top 20 list for Amazon’s #HQ2, but without the right preparation, could the results be disastrous?… https://t.co/kci8LpLm7f 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
Wednesday, join Philly Farm Crew (a join program of @JFarmSchool and @RTWPhilly) and a network of volunteers in the… https://t.co/PRTwq9CZBE 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
Should Philly adopt extreme risk protection orders to combat gun violence? Click the link for more info and then le… https://t.co/o1p8NQ6NRC 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
Black history is U.S. history. @NBA legend Charles Barkley highlights a month's worth of Philadelphia's African Ame… https://t.co/FeJQGqp7Sn 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
Did it upset you to learn that former PPA chief and accused sexual harasser Vince Fenerty is still a current ward l… https://t.co/hOtC4QWTAo 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
Make the new CitizenCast a part of your morning commute. This week, we call #TimesUp on accused sexual harasser and… https://t.co/N9wbbUcIQk 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
Philly’s on the top 20 list for Amazon’s #HQ2, but without the right preparation, could the results be disastrous?… https://t.co/JBDCBaksKP 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
"[Vince] Fenerty was Philadelphia’s version of Harvey Weinstein a year before the #MeToo movement." https://t.co/MuLa9AobjX 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
Are you a teacher or staff mbr who is ready to stand up and find a solution to the budgetary cuts in Philly schools… https://t.co/ZvenCwJaHH 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
"Students and teachers from 20 different high schools across the city spent the day hearing about five major chall… https://t.co/3Fjh28Pber 

LOAD MORE

Be a Citizen Editor

Suggest a Story