NEWSLETTER SIGNUP

By signing up to our newsletter, you agree to our terms.

Connor Barwin's Civic Season 2016

This week, the all-pro Eagle and citizen activist measures how our civic health stacks up against New York City

It’s election day, and if you do nothing else, please remember to show up at the polls. Given that (hopefully) we’ll all be doing our civic duty today, it makes sense to begin by diving into the comparison between our electoral turnout and New York’s.

As you can tell from the chart below, more registered voters turned out in our last mayoral election. But before we start celebrating, we should acknowledge that the turnout numbers for both cities is way too low, 25.5 percent here to 23.8 percent in New York.

Interestingly, New York has more of a tendency to elect moderate Republican mayors than we do. I put the question to Professor Richardson Dilworth of Drexel’s Center for Public Policy: Why is that?

“A major concern for Philadelphia Democrats is that, even if they elected someone who was a Republican in name only, such as New Yorkers did when they elected Michael Bloomberg, that person would still be beholden to the statewide Republican party, and it would once again lead to a monolithic shift in parties—which would also make Pennsylvania a solid Republican state in presidential elections,” Dilworth says. “In other words, sophisticated Philadelphia voters may actually be thinking of national politics when they vote against Republicans, even in our off-year local elections. This was certainly an idea the local Democratic party pushed when they were faced with the challenge of Sam Katz against John Street in 1999 and 2003. By contrast, Democratic New York has always had a political machine independent of the state—and Republicans elected mayors in New York tend to be seen as city-specific reformers running against the city Democratic machine, not as part of a state Republican machine. So local voters in New York City are in some respects more free to vote for Republicans as a protest against their own party than are voters in Philadelphia.”

Beyond the voting data, the thing that New York really beats Philadelphia on—and on which it beats every single Northeastern and Midwestern city—is population growth. “Between 2010 and 2015, New York City is estimated to have added about 375,000 more people to its population,” says Dilworth. “It’s as though, over five years, the entire population of Pittsburgh moved to New York City.”

But New York City loses to Philly on one critical datapoint: It is absurdly expensive. In 2010-2014 median family income in New York City was 40 percent higher than in Philadelphia ($52,737 versus $37460), but median value of owner-occupied housing was more than 240 percent higher: $490,700 vs. $143,200.

New York Idea We Should Steal: Linking Sustainability to Economic Development

Recently, when Mayor Kenney announced the city’s new sustainability plan, he said something important: “Sustainability is about more than the environment; it is also about tackling issues such as economic opportunity, health and neighborhood equity.”

Mayor Kenney has taken a page from New York’s groundbreaking connection nearly a decade ago between environmental policy and economic growth. Philadelphia’s new plan, building on Mayor Nutter’s policies, includes making sure that all Philadelphians have access to healthy and affordable food and water, clean air and safe and low-carbon transportation, while benefiting from the city’s parks, trees and waterways.

New York is proof positive of the efficacy of holistic sustainability policy—and of how far Philly could take its plan. Mayor Bloomberg unveiled PlaNYC in 2007, after seeing projections of his city’s population growth. He realized his environmental goals had to be integrated into the city’s economic development agenda. PlaNYC launched some 127 initiatives within a year, containing objectives ranging from the number of breakwaters made from oysters to cubic feet of natural gas captured from sewage plants. In the program’s first four years, the city added 200 acres of parkland while improving existing parks; preserved more than 64,000 units of affordable housing, and reduced greenhouse gas emissions by 13 percent. No wonder The New York Times wrote of PlaNYC: “Its fate could determine whether [Bloomberg’s] administration will be remembered as truly transformative.”

Current New York Mayor Bill de Blasio has updated PlaNYC, changing its name to OneNYC and adding an emphasis on policies that can shrink the income gap. De Blasio has pledged to cut carbon emissions 80 percent by 2050, largely by increasing energy efficiency in buildings. And he has continued Bloomberg’s emphasis on using data to drive policy. As Bloomberg liked to say: “In God we trust. Everyone else, bring data.”

Happy election day. Next week, we take on Atlanta.

Connor Barwin is the Eagles defensive end and runs the Make The World Better foundation, which works to refurbish city parks.

Results

Philadelphia

Eagles

vs

New York

Giants

# of B Corporations

27

7 POINTS

Giants

# of B Corporations

50

% Graduated high school in last school year

65

7 POINTS

Giants

% Graduated high school in last school year

70.5

Diversity Index

0.34

7 POINTS

Giants

Diversity Index

0.26

% Bike to work

1.9

7 POINTS

Eagles

% Bike to work

1.1

% Acres of park space

13

7 POINTS

Giants

% Acres of park space

20.8

Violent crime per 1,000 residents

10.2

7 POINTS

Giants

Violent crime per 1,000 residents

6

% Voted in last mayoral election

25.5

7 POINTS

Eagles

% Voted in last mayoral election

23.8

% Below poverty

26

7 POINTS

Giants

% Below poverty

20.9

Public transportation score

67

7 POINTS

Giants

Public transportation score

84

Final Score

14

New York

Giants

Final Score

49

Sep. 11
63-0

Eagles

Browns

Sep. 19
28-35

Bears

Bears

Sep. 25
35-28

Eagles

Steelers

Oct. 09
63-0

Eagles

Lions

Oct. 16
28-35

Redskins

Redskins

Oct. 23
28-35

Vikings

Vikings

Oct. 30
35-28

Eagles

Cowboys

Nov. 06
14-49

Giants

Giants

Nov. 13
56-7

Eagles

Falcons

Nov. 20
35-28

Eagles

Seahawks

Nov. 28
35-28

Eagles

Packers

Dec. 04
35-28

Eagles

Bengals

Dec. 11
28-35

Redskins

Redskins

Dec. 18
49-14

Eagles

Ravens

Dec. 22
14-49

Giants

Giants

Jan. 01
35-28

Eagles

Cowboys

Civic Record:

EAGLES

Wins

9

Losses

4

Upcoming Games:

 

For more information on this data, see the Civic Season Explained page.

Note: The Eagles play Washington, D.C., New York and Dallas twice this season, but we only count each city once in the Civic Record.

Recent Tweets
@THEPHILACITIZEN

@thephilacitizen @@thephilacitizen
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
Our weekly Do Something guide is your go-to source for civic engagement every week in #Philadelphia. https://t.co/tslCZp6PZD 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
"My theory is that we have to reform our criminal justice system while still being tough on criminals." https://t.co/dxz8A0uh5C 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
@ellisonreport offers a reality check on state plans to expand gaming and privatize liquor sales in the city. https://t.co/SFIX69lOa6 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
Our weekly Do Something Guide: Get Involved, Get Engaged, Get Going! https://t.co/mkHO21WYYQ https://t.co/575ZPstdQp 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
June is Reentry Awareness Month in Philadelphia. https://t.co/3lfeEiBCuu 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
The Philadelphia Citizen's Larry Platt spoke with AG Josh Shapiro on reducing recidivism in the state.… https://t.co/ZBFCoOia56 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
June is Reentry Awareness Month in Philadelphia. https://t.co/VOWiXPGvE0 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
Meet The Disruptors...AND their Mentors! The Citizen Member Happy Hour Event is fast-approaching. Get tickets here. https://t.co/bz6Yx42hqA 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
"There’s a lot of confidence in the ability of gaming and liquor to add cash to state coffers." https://t.co/7OZZFKcolj 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
Citizen Of The Week! @foodconnectphl founder, Megha Kulshreshtha, is solving the problem of food waste in the city. https://t.co/SkpFxykQra 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
Can Philadelphia pull itself out of the philanthropic giving doldrums? https://t.co/D5NtGO8qIw 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
MOVE Historical Marker Ceremony this Sat at 3pm, Osage Ave & Cobbs Creek PkWY with guest speaker @PoetSanchezhttps://t.co/y6x1QJntZM 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
Laugh-it-Forward with @NLC . This Saturday, June 24, 6-9 p.m. Asian Arts Initiative, 1219 Vine Street.… https://t.co/4GnYYwR04m 

LOAD MORE

Be a Citizen Editor

Suggest a Story