NEWSLETTER SIGNUP

Do Something

Be a better Philadelphia citizen

One of the founding tenets of The Philadelphia Citizen is to get people the resources they need to become better, more engaged citizens of their city.

We hope to do that in our Good Citizenship Toolkit, which includes a host of ways to get involved in Philadelphia — whether you want to contact your City Councilmember to voice your support for small businesses, get those experiencing homelessness the goods they need, or simply go out to dinner somewhere where you know your money is going toward a greater good.

Find an issue that’s important to you in the list below, and get started on your journey of A-plus citizenship.

Vote and strengthen democracy

Stand up for marginalized communities

Create a cleaner, greener Philadelphia

Help our local youth and schools succeed

Support local businesses

Connect WITH OUR SOCIAL ACTION TEAM



Your City Defined: City Controller

The city’s designated auditor has a lot of auditing to do

Your City Defined: City Controller

The city’s designated auditor has a lot of auditing to do

Wondering what the hell a City Controller is? You’re not alone — and you deserve congratulations for your civic-minded inquiry. Let’s take a trip into the mildly interesting world of city controlling, doing our best not to hit faces on keyboards along the way.

The Philadelphia City Controller’s Office was created in 1854. This was the same year that the first street-sweeping machine was put into service in the U.S. — on the streets of Philadelphia.

(That’s right, when Joseph Whitworth, the English inventor of the Mechanical Street Sweeper looked at our country, he apparently thought, I wonder where I can try out my new machine on the dirtiest, most awful streets in America. Philadelphia, you’ll do nicely!)

The City Controller’s job is a bit like street sweeper, but with numbers. The role derived its duties from the defunct County Auditor’s office. Which is pretty much the City Controller’s responsibilities in a nutshell. The City Controller is the city auditor. The controller also had to “countersign all warrants on the city treasurer” (the payment of city bills), and act as “a check on all heads of departments in matters of finance … mak[ing] reports thereon.”

Controllers kept the books, reporting what money went into and out of the city’s coffers each year. Just for fun, we could look at the annual report from the controller’s department in 1882. Philadelphia brought in $13.4 million in revenue. This was from very 19th-century sources such as city boiler inspections, fire-alarm telegraphs, ice-boats, and “huckster licenses.” Philadelphia spent $13.2 million in public services, so good on us in 1882 for being in the black. The controller was tasked with keeping tabs on all of these expenditures and publishing the reports “thereon.”

Fast-forward 140 years and the office of City Controller has evolved in the most … Philadelphian of ways. In an April 2013 debate, then-Controller, Alan Butkovitz, summed up what he saw as the duties of the office by saying, “[It] has become a credible anti-corruption agency, and is referring cases to the FBI and U.S. Attorney’s Office.”

Under former Controller Butkovitz, the Office of the Controller functioned almost as a judicial arm. Part IRS, part Inspector General, part FBI informant. He felt justified in turning an auditor’s office into a flashy anti-corruption agency merely because there are copious amounts of graft going on at any time in Philadelphia, most of which involve city funds.

Butkovitz used the controller’s office to focus on combating corruption, and he had some big wins.

  • “Inspired” then-Sheriff John Green to resign amid allegations he misappropriated real-estate sales and charged millions in bogus fees to the city.
  • Found time fraud and gross incompetency in two separate audits of the Revenue Department’s Mail Center.
  • Discovered fund misuse and profiteering among city charter schools, including  the Harambee Institute of Science and Technology (grades K-8) which was doubling after hours as Damani, a nightclub operating out of the school’s cafeteria.
  • Alleged Mayor Nutter’s administration used $380,000 from the proceeds of the Philadelphia Marathon as a personal “slush fund” for, among other things, expensive trips to Rome, $11,000 in alcohol, and $700 in Uber rides.

In 2017, Butkovitz’s job went to Rebecca Rhynhart, the first woman to hold the job. Rhynhart was less about flashy press conferences, more about data and efficiency. Before she resigned her post in 2022 to run for mayor, Rhynhart’s office researched and reported on:

The City Controller holds the power of audit.

They can use that power to chase corruption, as in the case of Alan Butkovitz. Or, they can focus on “identifying solutions that can save taxpayers millions of dollars,” a la Rebecca Rhynhart. But in neither case, can the controller implement the charges or changes they suggest.

Anti-corruption vs. Efficiency. Both approaches have historical precedent and, unfortunately for Philadelphia, both have relevance.

“It shall be the duty of the controller … upon the death, resignation, removal, or expiration of the term of officers who … may be authorized to receive or pay city moneys … to audit and examine the accounts and official acts of said officer, and if said officer shall be found indebted or liable to said city, a copy of the report … shall be filed in the court of Common Pleas.”

Financial policing stretches back to the earliest days of the office.

“The controller shall communicate at all times to the mayor and the committees of Councils such information upon the condition of the finances and the accounts of all officers expending or receiving the moneys of the city as [their] department can afford.”

So does communicating and collaborating within city departments.

The Office of the Controller is the city’s designated auditor. You can accomplish this task by focusing on bridges of cooperation and efficiency, or exposing Philly corruption.

 

MORE VERY PHILLY THINGS YOU OUGHTA UNDERSTAND

 

Header photo by Britt Reints via Flickr

The Philadelphia Citizen will only publish thoughtful, civil comments. If your post is offensive, not only will we not publish it, we'll laugh at you while hitting delete.

Be a Citizen Editor

Suggest a Story

Advertising Terms

We do not accept political ads, issue advocacy ads, ads containing expletives, ads featuring photos of children without documented right of use, ads paid for by PACs, and other content deemed to be partisan or misaligned with our mission. The Philadelphia Citizen is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit, nonpartisan organization and all affiliate content will be nonpartisan in nature. Advertisements are approved fully at The Citizen's discretion. Advertisements and sponsorships have different tax-deductible eligibility. For questions or clarification on these conditions, please contact Director of Sales & Philanthropy Kristin Long at [email protected] or call (609)-602-0145.