Do Something

Send us ideas for The Fix

Do you have an example of real integrity you’ve seen from our city government? Or, an example of the opposite?

Do you have a solution to the culture of contented corruption that swirls around us? Send us your ideas for The Fix.


The Fix: When The Empire Strikes Back

An attack on Controller Rebecca Rhynhart by the Mayor’s allies is straight from a familiar Philly playbook

The Fix: When The Empire Strikes Back

An attack on Controller Rebecca Rhynhart by the Mayor’s allies is straight from a familiar Philly playbook

If you happened to tune in to KYW news radio last week, you might have heard a story by veteran reporter Pat Loeb that aired some heavy criticisms of Controller Rebecca Rhynhart. You might have not thought much about the story: At first blush, after all, what’s noteworthy in Philly about a bunch of pols sniping at one another?

But let’s dissect it, because, in actuality, those 4 minutes and 46 seconds on KYW’s airwaves can serve as a window into a longstanding culture in this town that determines—often to the detriment of the common good—how things either do or don’t get done. In effect, it’s a primer on how the establishment here unites against any change agent, to protect their little islands of turf.

Listen for yourself:

Let’s get real about what’s happening here. First, consider the context: the story of Jim Kenney’s mayoralty is in danger of becoming a narrative of incompetence. He can’t find $33 million in missing taxpayer funds; he touts a tax increase as his singular accomplishment, but a good amount of the pre-K centers it initially funded hadn’t conducted background checks for employees and owed the city back taxes; and his vacillation on whether to move Made In America from the Parkway, as captured by Inquirer cartoonist Signe Wilkinson, made him look small and indecisive.

So it should come as no surprise that Kenney and his allies have reverted to the tried-and-true—and Trump-like—Philly playbook. By criticizing Rhynhart, who, along with Councilman Allan Domb, has brought to light major city accounting errors, they’re playing a familiar game of blame the messenger. As I recounted when we announced this series, our town’s history of private interests trumping the common good dates back at least to Lincoln Steffens’ muckraking reporting in the early 1900s, and continues today. Make no mistake: The criticism of Rhynhart today is consistent with that tradition. It’s the status quo, striking back.

Her KYW critics suggest that, during her time as Treasurer under Mayor Michael Nutter, Rhynhart oversaw many of the same errors she is now unearthing. However, according to a report by her predecessor, Alan Butkovitz, $1.1 billion in accounting errors under Rhynhart were cleaned up by the end of her tenure. And there are rebuttals that could be made to all of the criticisms. But rather than go deep into those weeds, let’s get to the broader point.

Do SomethingIf they wanted, her critics could hold Rhynhart’s audits up to intellectual scrutiny. One way to do that would be to interview unbiased experts about them, people like Ed DeSeve, a Philadelphian and beyond-reproach national leader in municipal finance. But the KYW story instead interviews Kenney allies, and gives them unquestioned space to throw political broadsides and plainly inaccurate critiques.

In this scenario, former Controller Jonathan Saidel, the mayoral appointee chosen to lead the joke of a task force looking into the city’s accounting woes, plays Devin Nunes—congressional overseer turned Trump lackey. Then there’s Donna Cooper, a former Rendell policy advisor and soda tax supporter who now heads the nonprofit Public Citizens for Children & Youth, mounting a decidedly political defense of the Kenney administration by accusing Rhynhart of operating in “an overtly political manner.”

The third critic—Butkovitz—is no ally of Kenney’s (and is, in fact, considering challenging the mayor in the 2019 primary) but might not be the most credible source when it comes to Rhynhart, who defeated him at the polls.

Read More

Let’s get beyond this particular story as a referendum on either Rhynhart or Kenney. The bigger point is that what we’re witnessing here is part of a type. Sam Katz, who has forgotten more about Philadelphia than most of us will ever know, says that politics here “hugs the status quo,” a lovely phrase for a maddening practice.

It’s true: Our history is replete with characters who might not even qualify in other towns as profiles in courage, but who, trying to make things better for all of us, have publicly asked questions of the permanent establishment…and suffered the consequences. Because there is historically little tolerance in Philadelphia for those who, placing common good ahead of narrow interests, have the temerity to wonder if there might be a better way.

Just off the top of my head, a list comes to mind of those who have asked questions and questioned answers in Philadelphia—at their own peril:

  • Remember Heidi Ramirez, an impressive academic named to the School Reform Commission, who dared question the budgeting and managerial prowess of then-Superintendent Arlene Ackerman? When Ackerman came down on her, the politicians who had thrust Ramirez into the spotlight were nowhere to be found. 
  • Autumn Adkins Graves, who served as the first African-American and first female president of Girard College from 2009 to 2012 sought to be a change-maker. But her Board consisted of many who were accustomed to saying “That’s not the way we do things here.” (Any Board that includes the city’s Register of Wills—God bless Ron Donatucci, a good man—is not one that is likely to shake things up). She resigned, citing family reasons.
  • Or how about Ellen Green-Ceisler, now a Commonwealth Court judge, whose reports documented cases of police misconduct in her role as the department’s Integrity and Accountability Officer in the early aughts. But then-Commissioner Sylvester Johnson and the late Jerry Mondesire, then-head of the NAACP, not only criticized her for airing the department’s dirty laundry—they declared that her office had outlived its usefulness and shut it down in 2005.
  • Finally, back in the mid ‘90s, the Phillies, led by David Montgomery and Bill and Joe Giles, pushed for a ballpark at Broad and Spring Garden. At the time, urban ballparks were reinvigorating city streets across the country, as in Denver, where local tax revenues tripled within six years of the opening of Coors Field in a formerly blighted neighborhood. Here, though, the narrowest of interests won out over the public good: Then-State Senator Vince Fumo (before his corruption conviction and prison term) squashed the Center City ballpark idea because of its proximity to his Fairmount mansion. And there was no one to stand up to him, just like there doesn’t seem to be anyone to speak for the taxpayer today when Mayor Kenney seeks to raise more taxes—while unable to locate millions of dollars he’s already been given.

These are all relatively recent examples. Leave it to the encyclopedic Katz to provide a most fitting historical case study: Smedley Butler. Butler was a Marine Corps Major General and, at the time of his 1940 death, the most decorated Marine in United States history, one of only 19 men to receive the Medal of Honor twice. In 1924, during the height of Prohibition, Butler came to Philadelphia to become the city’s Director of Public Safety and announced he was going to clean up the famously corrupt police and fire departments. He assaulted the city’s go-along-to-get-along culture. He replaced corrupt cops, raided speakeasies, and took on bootlegging, prostitution, gambling and political corruption. He even set his sights on the city’s elite, raiding the Ritz-Carlton and Union League.

After less than two years in office, Butler was run out of town by that era’s ruling class; then-Mayor W. Freehand Kendrick brilliantly spun it: “I had the guts to bring General Butler to Philadelphia and I have the guts to fire him.” Butler’s precipitous fall prompted the war hero to remark, “Cleaning up Philadelphia was worse than any battle I was ever in.”

It’s said that Rhynhart has been taken aback by the ferocity of the criticism Kenney and his minions have thrown her way. But maybe Ol’ Smedley and the others can be a cautionary tale for her, but not in the way you might think. The lesson from the way the insider class operates in Philadelphia ought not to be an inducement to pull punches, so much as a warning sign that you’re going to have to take a few.

The Fix is made possible through a grant from the Thomas Skelton Harrison Foundation. The Harrison Foundation does not exercise editorial control or approval over the content of any material published by The Philadelphia Citizen.

Header photo illustration by Syra Ortiz-Blanes.

The Philadelphia Citizen will only publish thoughtful, civil comments. If your post is offensive, not only will we not publish it, we'll laugh at you while hitting delete.

Be a Citizen Editor

Suggest a Story

Advertising Terms

We do not accept political ads, issue advocacy ads, ads containing expletives, ads featuring photos of children without documented right of use, ads paid for by PACs, and other content deemed to be partisan or misaligned with our mission. The Philadelphia Citizen is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit, nonpartisan organization and all affiliate content will be nonpartisan in nature. Advertisements are approved fully at The Citizen's discretion. Advertisements and sponsorships have different tax-deductible eligibility. For questions or clarification on these conditions, please contact Director of Sales & Philanthropy Kristin Long at [email protected] or call (609)-602-0145.