NEWSLETTER SIGNUP

By signing up to our newsletter, you agree to our terms.

Playoff Week 2: Mike Quick's Eagles Civic Season

This week, the Eagles announcer and former All-Pro wide receiver, with help from a Drexel professor, looks at how Philly stacks up against New Orleans—on and off the field

Following in the tradition of Connor Barwin and Malcolm Jenkins, former All-Pro wide receiver and current Eagles broadcaster Mike Quick will write weekly for The Citizen this season, analyzing what the Birds will have to do each week on the field to emerge victorious. We’ve paired Quick with Professor Richardson Dilworth, Director of Drexel University’s Center for Public Policy, who will analyze how Philly stacks up off-the-field against the city we play each week. Dilworth, who knows nothing about football, is arguably Quick’s most unlikely teammate ever.

Mike Quick’s On-Field Scouting Report: Let’s get this out of the way first: We’re a different team than the one that was manhandled 48-7 by New Orleans on November 18. The Eagles defense not only tackles better now, but is also more in synch. Defensive mistakes led directly to numerous touchdowns in that previous game, and they were the kind of mistakes the Eagles defense is no longer making.

That said, beating the Saints to keep this magical run going is going to be a tall task. New Orleans is still, in my mind, the best all-around team in the league. Their quarterback, Drew Brees, is a first ballot Hall of Famer, and he’s got enough weapons on his team that, no matter what you take away from him, there always seems to be another guy stepping up to make plays.

So how do you stop Brees and his runaway offense? The answer is you hit the quarterback. You push the pocket in on him so he can’t step up in it and give himself room to set up and throw. Brees is only 6 feet tall, so that gives an advantage to a defensive line that’s able to collapse the pocket and take away the quarterback’s time. Fletcher Cox, Tim Jernigan, Brandon Graham and Chris Long have got to make Drew Brees uncomfortable all day long.

One thing that will work in the Eagles favor is just how well Doug Pederson prepares his team. Time and again, Doug has shown an ability to identify the weakness of the other team and exploit it.

It’s been a great run. Fasten your seat belts!

Prof. Richardson Dilworth’s Off-Field Scouting Report: First, I’m sorry, but New Orleans is a cooler city than Philadelphia. It just is. Its history is far cooler than our incredibly dull history (New Orleans: We were French then Spanish then French again and then part of the US; Philadelphia: We are Quakers who are good at things like banking and insurance and sitting in silence for long periods of time). Like Mike Quick says, its food is better. All you have to do is spend 15 minutes walking around both cities and New Orleans wins hands down.

But, at least Philadelphia will be around later in the century while New Orleans may be entirely decimated by the impacts of climate change. In the latter half of this century we can expect all cities to experience higher temperatures, greater energy demands that may outstrip existing capacity, land made uninhabitable by rising sea levels and more frequent storms, urban ecosystems disrupted by things such as invasive species, and greater chances of infectious diseases.

Given New Orleans’s location, it will probably become unbearably hot far sooner than Philadelphia, and it is more at risk from sea level rise and storms. Just take a look at this little report from Zillow (which is, oddly enough, a great source for learning about the impacts of climate change on housing). You can see that Louisiana ranks only behind Florida and Hawaii in terms of the likely expected loss in housing—with much of that loss no doubt concentrated in New Orleans.

At the same time, sometimes disastrous conditions lead to unexpected outcomes. This was certainly the case with Hurricane Katrina. After the storm, New Orleans was decimated in a way that Philadelphia really never has been, with the possible exception of the 1793 yellow fever epidemic. Between 2005 and 2006, while Philadelphians were celebrating the fact that we were, after half a century basically maintaining a steady population, New Orleans lost more than half its residents.

Yet since that time it has made a pretty remarkable recovery. First, its school system—which nearly everyone thought was pretty disastrous—was basically replaced by a system of charter schools, and its test scores have since made a marked improvement. Second, its population has mostly returned, though it appears that it will be a permanently smaller city of about 400,000. Third, its economic segregation, and the percent of the population living in areas of concentrated poverty, has decreased. And finally, it is more resilient than ever, thanks in large part to federal investments through the US Army Corps of Engineers.

New Orleans post-Katrina is of course not all good, and it can in fact be characterized as simply a storm-inspired gentrification, as many of the poor in the city were permanently displaced—which may well explain the greater number of people in New Orleans with bachelors degrees. The new charter school system has become a poster child for conservative school reform advocates, and many of the successes can most likely be attributed to short-term funding increases through foundations, and lower personnel costs that will likely not last (see this informative article here). And no matter the level of resilient infrastructure, nothing is going to stop the heat from rising in an already sweltering city, which will no doubt lower the life expectancies especially of those people who cannot afford air conditioning, which will no doubt become more expensive as energy demand increases.

Philadelphia will experience a much milder climate change impact, at least in the short run. In the long run this may be worse, as the impacts will be less disruptive and thus demand less immediate and dramatic responses. We will be less prepared for disasters that will become more common and we will have not made as smart investments in things that will reduce the heat island effect or reduce energy demands.



Results:

Philadelphia

Eagles

vs

New Orleans

Saints

# of B Corps

25

Eagles

# of B Corps

2

% Population with a BA

27.4

Saints

% Population with a BA

36

% Volunteers

26.5

Eagles

% Volunteers

16.2

Violent Crime per 1000 people

9.9

Eagles

Violent Crime per 1000 people

10.9

Diversity Rating

69.7

Eagles

Diversity Rating

48.2

% People Bike to Work

2.2

Saints

% People Bike to Work

3.3

% Acres of Park Space

13.1

Saints

% Acres of Park Space

25.7

Public Transportation Score

67

Eagles

Public Transportation Score

44

% Voters in Last Mayoral Election

24

Saints

% Voters in Last Mayoral Election

33.3

Final Score

42

Philadelphia

Eagles

Final Score

21

Sep. 06
49-14

Eagles

Falcons

Sep. 16
42-21

Eagles

Buccaneers

Sep. 23
49-14

Eagles

Colts

Sep. 30
49-14

Eagles

Titans

Oct. 07
28-35

Vikings

Vikings

Oct. 11
21-42

Giants

Giants

Oct. 21
42-21

Eagles

Panthers

Oct. 28
35-28

Eagles

Jaguars

Nov. 11
35-28

Eagles

Cowboys

Nov. 18
42-21

Eagles

Saints

Nov. 25
21-42

Giants

Giants

Dec. 03
21-42

Redskins

Redskins

Dec. 09
35-28

Eagles

Cowboys

Dec. 16
42-21

Eagles

Rams

Dec. 23
42-21

Eagles

Texans

Dec. 29
21-42

Redskins

Redskins

Jan. 06
42-21

Eagles

Bears

Jan. 13
42-21

Eagles

Saints

Civic Record:

EAGLES

Wins

11

Losses

3

Upcoming Games:


For more information on this data, see the Civic Season Explained page.

Research by Madison Raju.

Be a Citizen Editor

Suggest a Story