Do Something

Vote on November 5

City Council has the power to make big decisions that affect all of us. Even if parking happens to be the only issue you care about, voting matters!

As Geeting points out in today’s article, City Council is about to see a big generational turnover, and we’re hopefully going to see some other backward ideas start to fall off the agenda, as well.

None of that can happen without you, though.

A full list of candidates running in the upcoming election is available here. Do your research and be an informed voter!



This video breaks down the high cost of free parking

Check out this explainer video from Vox for an introduction to this debate and why it matters so much for the overall housing and transportation picture.

Is Council’s Love of Parking Finally Over?

As Philly 3.0’s engagement director notes, new members could bring even more sense to the ongoing debate over zoning code parking minimums

Is Council’s Love of Parking Finally Over?

As Philly 3.0’s engagement director notes, new members could bring even more sense to the ongoing debate over zoning code parking minimums

One of the long-running sagas we’ve been following here since 2016 is the push from Council President Darrell Clarke and 3rd District Councilmember Jannie Blackwell to increase minimum parking requirements in the zoning code——a regressive tax that makes housing more expensive. It’s an idea so bad there’s a whole 800-page book devoted to how terrible it is.

This is an issue where the gap between what the evidence says and where the politics are is especially wide, but as the consensus against minimum parking requirements has hardened among planners and activists in housing and transportation fields over the last 25 years, the politics have slowly started to change.


City Councils in peer cities like Buffalo, Minneapolis, and just recently San Francisco have voted to fully eliminate their parking requirements on the basis of affordability and environmental concerns, and Philadelphia made real progress reducing ours in the Zoning Code Commission package passed in 2011.

But during this Council term, there was a rearguard push by some of the members who had never gotten on board with those changes—most prominently Darrell Clarke, Jannie Blackwell, Bill Greenlee and Brian O’Neill— to turn back the clock, and they’ve spent the past three years unsuccessfully promoting a bill that would bump the parking quotas back up in random ways.

Now, after one last-minute push during the lame-duck session this fall, it looks like the bill is likely dead, with Councilmember Blackwell telling Jake Blumgart at PlanPhilly she doesn’t have the votes. The bill, which was first introduced in 2016, shelved, and then shelved again after an attempt to revive it last summer, had been scheduled for a Rules Committee hearing last week but was pulled from the agenda. Blackwell says that’s because it doesn’t have the support to pass:

“I don’t have the support, it’s that simple,” said Blackwell, during a phone interview about the future of her parking legislation. “I didn’t have support the last time, but I thought I’d try again while I’m here. For some reason, and I can’t pretend to understand why, I can’t get my colleagues to support it.”

There’s a very limited window this fall to still pass the bill, but if the votes aren’t there, it’s likely not going to be rescheduled in the Rules Committee. Blumgart says the push could continue on in the next City Council term, but the vote math only gets more difficult for Clarke next year.

City Council President Darrell Clarke is also a supporter of increasing parking minimums, so the end of Blackwell’s career will not end the support for the policy in the city’s legislative body.

At the end of the spring session, he introduced legislation to create a Zoning Code Review Commission, under his control, to propose reforms that would include increased parking minimums.

But in addition to the loss of Blackwell’s vote, another consistent Clarke ally, William Greenlee, is retiring. Republican Councilmember Brian O’Neill, who shares many of Clarke’s perspectives on zoning, is facing his first serious challenger in decades this November.

Not only are two certain “Yes” votes for parking minimums (Blackwell and Greenlee) not returning to Council in January, but they’ll be replaced by two certain No votes from Kathy Gilmore-Richardson and Jamie Gauthier, who both went on record with their support for eliminating parking minimums during the primary campaign.

They’re joined by two incumbents Allan Domb and Maria Quinones-Sanchez (who is sometimes allied with Clarke on housing legislation), and threeAt-Large general election candidates: Kendra Brooks, Joe Cox and Republican Matt Wolfe. On top of all that, having the Rules Committee Chair be someone other than Bill Greenlee in the next term is itself a major blow to the cause.

So not only is there going to be no support in the next Council term for increasing minimum parking requirements, but there may actually be a political opening to further reduce or eliminate them in some cases. It’s a welcome reminder that City Council really is about to see a big generational turnover next year and we’re hopefully going to see some other backward ideas start to fall off the agenda as well.

Jon Geeting is the director of engagement at Philadelphia 3.0, a political action committee that supports efforts to reform and modernize City Hall. This is part of a series of articles running in both The Citizen and 3.0’s blog.

The Philadelphia Citizen will only publish thoughtful, civil comments. If your post is offensive, not only will we not publish it, we'll laugh at you while hitting delete.

Be a Citizen Editor

Suggest a Story

Advertising Terms

We do not accept political ads, issue advocacy ads, ads containing expletives, ads featuring photos of children without documented right of use, ads paid for by PACs, and other content deemed to be partisan or misaligned with our mission. The Philadelphia Citizen is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit, nonpartisan organization and all affiliate content will be nonpartisan in nature. Advertisements are approved fully at The Citizen's discretion. Advertisements and sponsorships have different tax-deductible eligibility. For questions or clarification on these conditions, please contact Director of Sales & Philanthropy Kristin Long at [email protected] or call (609)-602-0145.