NEWSLETTER SIGNUP

By signing up to our newsletter, you agree to our terms.

Do Something

File a complaint with OIG

If you suspect wrongdoing by someone in city government, you can submit an anonymous report on the OIG’s website. You can also call them at 215-686-1770.

Connect WITH OUR SOCIAL ACTION TEAM



Your City Defined: Office of the Inspector General

The office recovered more than $70 million in fraud just in the last eight years

The office recovered more than $70 million in fraud just in the last eight years

When a reader thinks of an Inspector General they might, like me, picture a person of military persuasion walking up and down the front lines…inspecting things. A very old and proud tradition this would be, dating back to the Revolutionary War when Inspectors General weaved between militia lines, threw up their hands in frustration, and said, “Well, you boys tried at least. Now off to war with you.”

In reality, the civilian office dates back to the not-quite-Colonial times of 1976. In that olden year the first commercial supercomputer was flipped on, Steve Jobs formed Apple, and the 94th Congress created the Office of the Inspector General to combat “fraud and abuse in Medicare [and] Medicaid…”

The city of Philadelphia had established an Office of Performance Assessment a few months earlier, but in February of 1985, Mayor W. Wilson Goode renamed it the Office of the Inspector General because, I assume, “performance assessment” sounds like something every employee already hates. The main function of the Inspector General is to “root out corruption, fraud, misconduct, waste, and mismanagement” in order to “boost public confidence in city government.” A shot of confidence is great (and in light of past corruption scandals severely needed), but the office also specializes in making an example of ne’er-do-wells and recovering or saving the city boatloads of money—over $70 million during the past eight years.

More than 320 city employees have been “held accountable” by the Office of the Inspector General since 2008 (which is as far back as the OIG’s published reports appear to go). Some of those investigations netted your classic defrauders like Barry Jones, a contractor who submitted phony time sheets to the city between 2004 and 2008 and made off with a million dollars. Other investigations are decidedly a bit odd as a perusal of the OIG’s recent cases demonstrates:

  • Calvin Duncan, a former employee of the Philadelphia Water Department ordered $1.3 million worth of printer ink and toner cartridges between 2006 and 2012. Then he brazenly used the Water Department’s own UPS account to ship the ink supplies to a laser cartridge company in Arkansas, pocketing more than  half a million dollars in the process. Amy Kurland, our current Inspector General, testified at Duncan’s sentencing, and made the cogent point, “When people are able to steal that amount of money from the city, it makes citizens lose confidence in government.” It really does. It makes them ask questions like what did the city think Duncan was doing with all those ink cartridges? Because if it’s not printing off the Harry Potter series for every person at the Water Department, something is probably up.
  • Shamira Hawkins-Worthey, a former employee of the Department of Human Services, stole an astonishing number of SEPTA tokens over a nine-month period in 2013. She pilfered more than 11,000 tokens, which were supposed to be “provided to children, parents and family members who must commute to court hearings…and other official events consistent with the Department’s child welfare missions.” Hawkins-Worthey forged the signatures of supervisors and made requests to provide tokens for cases, many of which were inactive, closed or “did not exist.” She was charged with a staggering 1,576 counts of “Theft, Forgery, and Tampering with Public Records,” representing an initial loss to the city of more than $24,000.
  • Then there’s the disturbing (and ironic) case of Nathaniel Robinson who, between 2006 and 2010, allegedly stole $154,000 dollars in federal funds while being employed at a non-profit organization that helps the homeless (SELF, Inc.). Among other things, Robinson made purchases at Best Buy, IKEA, Sears, Walmart, and made “lodging charges, including charges at hotels on weekends.” Just let that one sink in for a moment. Robinson stole money from the homeless…to pay for lodgings and furnishings…for his home.

Whew. If cases like these don’t underscore the need for a city-wide Inspector General’s office, I can’t imagine what does.

The OIG does have its limits, though.  While it is “functionally independent,” it is still part of the executive branch. This sets up a clear conflict of interest: As Inspector General Kurland notes, a mayor “could come in and eliminate the office with a stroke of the pen,” which might make the OIG less inclined to investigate fraud that emanates from the Mayor’s office. When he was a council member, Mayor Jim Kenney submitted legislation to make the OIG truly independent, but it never made it to committee and died on the vine. In those days, at least, he supported an independent OIG. Now that he’s the mayor, might he push Council again to turn the office loose?

Since 2008, over 700 complaints have been filed to the Inspector General’s office by city employees. Importantly, almost the same number (more than 600) have come from ordinary Philadelphia citizens. According to the 2015 annual report, “Without the hundreds of anonymous tips that come in from brave, committed citizens each year, the OIG’s work would not be as effective.” A whistleblower act that was passed in 2010 protects the identity of anyone who reports to the OIG; so as far as fraud is concerned, “Report ‘em if you got ‘em.” I may be remembering that phrase wrong. Eh, it still applies.

Header photo: Flickr/Jack Donaghy

The Philadelphia Citizen will only publish thoughtful, civil posts. We want to be a communal space. But that doesn’t mean you have a First Amendment right to be an idiot. Send us an insulting, offensive and/or wildly off-topic comment and not only will we refrain from posting it -- we will laugh at you before we hit delete.

Recent Tweets
@THEPHILACITIZEN

@thephilacitizen @@thephilacitizen
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
Have an opinion on Amnesty Bill #160111, which would allow delinquent ticket-holders the opportunity to pay $50 to… https://t.co/Ucl4rECg3J 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
Know someone who’s being bullied at school? Read the Philadelphia School District’s policies and procedures, and cl… https://t.co/QDUXn2HFmU 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
Our @Eagles go up against the @nyjets plus @MalcolmJenkins discusses two organizations working to bring the topic o… https://t.co/JxyV2w9UH1 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
Help a pet in need find their furever home this weekend with a Mega Adoption Event. Join the @BrandywineSPCA and fi… https://t.co/SNfSIThshC 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
Help to put an end to poverty by feeding the homeless this Saturday at Dilworth Park with D.O.P.E. INC. Can't make… https://t.co/YBJC2hoYBk 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
Support local artists this evening with the @the_barnes! Free admission and access to local artwork, gift ideas and… https://t.co/ijkKQXt6yu 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
You can't get the great house without the great job with the great salary and...well... isn't it about time somebod… https://t.co/JeQX15NaJM 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
As we move closer towards the @Eagles winning the #SuperBowl (yeah, we said it!) All-Pro safety @MalcolmJenkins pro… https://t.co/s9hQrRJAJV 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
The Oxford Dictionaries Word of the Year for 2017 is..."Youthquake." Can we use it in a sentence? Sure! "The Letter… https://t.co/RfTXSUJ5r4 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
"KickUp measures impact at a granular level, through software that follows individual teachers from training to cla… https://t.co/MWb3sCdAXB 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
We want your feedback! What topics of discussion are important to you and your community? Let us know!… https://t.co/TJ0RkbBcJr 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
Eagles v Jets and two organizations on the frontline of reentry are profiled by @Eagles All-Pro Safety and Citizen… https://t.co/CsHP15DJKU 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
"Give a kid a flower pot, a hard floor, and permission to drop it as many times as like." Read more: https://t.co/QT0xVE1Yya 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
What's the problem? What's the #Solution? It’s easy to weigh in: read more to tell us your idea, or text at 215-774… https://t.co/dHQwb6RvoX 

LOAD MORE

Be a Citizen Editor

Suggest a Story