NEWSLETTER SIGNUP

By signing up to our newsletter, you agree to our terms.

Do Something

Make your voice heard on healthcare

Whether you’re a Democrat, Republican, or other, health care is a critical issue. Call your representatives and tell them how you want them to move forward with our nation’s health care system.

Connect WITH OUR SOCIAL ACTION TEAM



Guest Commentary: What Does Success Mean, Mr. President?

A local rabbi calls on President Trump to remember the interests of his supporters, to make America greater for all

A local rabbi calls on President Trump to remember the interests of his supporters, to make America greater for all

The Citizen will publish guest articles, like this one, that add to the local civic discussion. To submit, click here.

Dear Mr. President,

The defeat of the “American Health Care Act” must be a bitter experience for you. It has been referred to as a humiliating defeat, a train wreck, a disaster . . . well, you have heard it all. It can’t be good to hear. No one likes to experience failure in such a public, grand way. I can’t imagine you do.

Rabbi Seymour Rosenbloom, President Donald Trump, open letter,
Rabbi Seymour Rosenbloom

But the question is what will you do with your failure? Will you own it or blame others? Will you be embittered and compile an enemies list? Or will you figure out what went wrong? Will you acknowledge what has been going wrong almost from the day you took office?

I confess, I did not vote for you. Frankly, I was afraid of you. I still am. Of your demagoguery. Of your authoritarian personality. Of your outrageous accusations. Of your appeals to racism, sexism, xenophobia and jingoism.

But as both President Obama and Secretary Clinton said, we are all Americans. And you are our only president. No one wants you to fail. Because then America will fail. If you succeed, our nation succeeds.

But what will success mean?

You say you want to make America great again. I believe that America is already great. But can we at least agree that America can be greater than it is?

I hope that the debacle you allowed yourself to become embroiled in will be a wake-up call to remember the interests of the people who put their faith in you and elected you to be our president.

You are a Republican. But the Republican establishment did not elect you. The Americans who gave you your electoral college majority are men and women who have lost faith in the accessibility of the American dream. They have lost faith in government as a vehicle to make their lives better. They saw you as their standard-bearer, their defender. To make America great again for them.

They did not vote for you because you promised them the Republican dream. They voted for you because you promised them their American dream.

When it came to health care, they couldn’t care less about the Republican article of faith to repeal and replace Obamacare. They wanted what you promised them: A great health care plan, at a fraction of the cost they are now paying. And while they may have thought your promise was an exaggeration, they believed in your sincerity. They believed you would fight for them to get greater access to the health care they need, at a lower cost.

Instead, you squandered your political capital supporting a House Republican bill that would have made quality health care out of the reach of many of the people who voted for you. It was a bill designed to restrict health care, and give enormous tax breaks to the wealthy. And that is precisely the hypocrisy and flim-flam that your supporters detest in government. They thought you were a straight talker, a no-nonsense representative. But you allowed yourself to get caught up in the shenanigans of the craven, venal, deceptive and divisive agenda advanced by Republicans in Congress.

When it comes to that agenda, there is very little in it other than the discredited notion that tax cuts will improve society, and that individuals can best care for themselves without a government that has the best interests of individual Americans at heart. The Republican notion that if the rich get richer everyone lives better has been disproven as a selfish delusion time and time again. It is only the very rich who can get by without some form of government assistance in their lives. And even they look to expand their wealth and power through government action—or inaction.

Mr. President, what will you do with your failure? Will you own it or blame others? Will you be embittered and compile an enemies list? Or will you figure out what went wrong? Will you acknowledge what has been going wrong almost from the day you took office?

As for health care, everyone will concede that the Affordable Care Act, Obamacare, needs modifications. House Speaker Paul Ryan has now conceded that “Obamacare is the law of the land” and will be “for the foreseeable future.” Instead of abandoning health care reform, isn’t this an opportune time for you to engage Democrats, who want to be able to improve Obamacare without the threat of dismantling it? Wouldn’t all Americans benefit from both parties working to make the well-being of citizens their primary goal?

I hope that the debacle you allowed yourself to become embroiled in will be a wake-up call to remember the interests of the people who put their faith in you and elected you to be our president. Yes, this constituency wants better American jobs. They want safety. And they want secure borders. But they also want good schools, quality health care they can afford, clean air and water, and global cooperation.

President Carter coined the phrase “a government as good as its people.”

Mr. President, if you make your agenda the transformation of our government into one that is as good as our people, and if you put the interests of the people of our great nation first, you will achieve the admiration and gratitude of all citizens, whatever their political affiliation. You can still create a legacy that will make your presidency a great one.

Sincerely yours,

Rabbi Seymour Rosenbloom

Rabbi Seymour Rosenbloom is the Distinguished Service Rabbi (retired) of Congregation Adath Jeshurun in Elkins Park, PA. He is the immediate past president of JSPAN, the Jewish Social Policy Action Network.

Photo header: Flickr/Andres Castellano

The Philadelphia Citizen will only publish thoughtful, civil posts. We want to be a communal space. But that doesn’t mean you have a First Amendment right to be an idiot. Send us an insulting, offensive and/or wildly off-topic comment and not only will we refrain from posting it -- we will laugh at you before we hit delete.

Recent Tweets
@THEPHILACITIZEN

@thephilacitizen @@thephilacitizen
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
“If I can just make a difference in one woman’s life like that, then I’ve done my job.” Disruptor: @AnaOnoIntimates https://t.co/07M4NXhZPo 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
THURS @TempleUniv's Nora Wilson will host an event on how to administer NARCAN in the face of Philly's drug crises. https://t.co/GjuB3aa2PY 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
"The Sky is the Limit" 17 hosted by @ATTRACTPhilly this Saturday, 1PM at Penrose Rec. This event is free. https://t.co/2vYJqONEdq 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
Tomorrow @PhilaSoup comes to @magicgardens for their annual Kick Off! Join them and help Philly students. 6-9PM $15 https://t.co/Blie1YPEgk 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
After decades of disinvestment and disruption, Philadelphia's 60th Street business corridor plots its comeback.… https://t.co/MdgChe1RKX 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
Scratched #SolarEclipse2017 shades cannot be reused in 2024 according to @NASA but they can be recycled. https://t.co/24QGcTcvkQ 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
"The solution to those problems may lie in the small city of Macon, Georgia." #Philadelphia #bikegrids #macongeorgia https://t.co/CSpD5vD2tH 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
“Our disease is not being treated equal,” Meet Monday's Disruptor: Dana Donofree with @AnaOnoIntimates. https://t.co/07M4NXhZPo 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
Did you miss last week's Reality Check? @ellisonreport with the story on Rizzo and his statue. #OnWurd https://t.co/sKdIlcfQAc 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
Our own @quinnocallaghan sat in with @onwurd a few weeks back to discuss race. Read the thoughtful companion piece. https://t.co/QennLkHPwa 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
Join @officialsouthst from 6-8PM & speak w/ city officials, police & community mbrs on homelessness & solutions. https://t.co/NRNq9P3lP9 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
Could a measure similar to Macon Ga's temporary bike grid change things for bicyclists here in Philadelphia?… https://t.co/3Y5cjLZCjL 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
Watch the solar eclipse, party with @PhilaSoup and more this week with our Do Something guide to civic engagement. https://t.co/dqQwodYgHB 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
“I feel more fulfilled and happier in my life than I ever have,” Dana Donofree with @AnaOnoIntimates https://t.co/07M4NX0oqO 

LOAD MORE

Be a Citizen Editor

Suggest a Story