NEWSLETTER SIGNUP

By signing up to our newsletter, you agree to our terms.

Do Something

Who's financing who?

Click here to review the most recent Philadelphia campaign finance reports.

Connect WITH OUR SOCIAL ACTION TEAM



Corruption Cards

Collect them all

A few months back, we created a full set of Philadelphia Corruption All Star playing cards, the kind you can print out and trade with your friends. Hard to say who’s worth more: Buddy “I’m going to steal every vote I can” Cianfrani, Raymond “I’m not a Boy Scout” Lederer or Leanne “I am the f$#ing Senator” Washington. You decide.

 

Legally Corrupt

When the head of the local NAACP is secretly part of the Mayor’s pro-soda tax team, it proves that our most insidious corruption is perfectly legal

When the head of the local NAACP is secretly part of the Mayor’s pro-soda tax team, it proves that our most insidious corruption is perfectly legal

You may have missed this latest nugget late last week. Some enterprising reporters at The Daily News noticed a curious name on Mayor Kenney’s latest campaign finance report. Someone named Rodney Carpenter had been paid $25,000 by the mayor’s political action committee since April.

This story made possible by our members.
Become a member today

Well, no Rodney Carpenter shows up on a Google search. But the address for Carpenter listed on Kenney’s report, the reporters found, was the same as the North Broad Street home of Nation of Islam Muhammad Mosque No. 12. Could Rodney Carpenter be a pseudonym for Minister Rodney Muhammad, who is also president of the Philadelphia NAACP?

You bet. Turns out, Muhammad has been paid as a consultant by the mayor’s pro-soda tax lobbying machine—the same regressive tax that disproportionately adversely affects the poor, many of whom are African American. The Kenney campaign spokesman couldn’t even tell the Daily News reporters just what Muhammad did for his $25,000.

Subterfuge notwithstanding, this would appear to be no big deal, right? This  kind of thing is business as usual in Philly, right? Sadly, yes. Welcome to the most insidious type of Philadelphia corruption: The perfectly legal kind.

Minister Rodney Muhammad

Tales of Seth Williams’ pilfering, Kathleen Kane’s lies under oath and Chaka Fattah’s bank fraud get the bold headlines, as well they should. Our shameful history of political scoundrels even led us to publish our Philly Corruption All-Star playing cards—you can trade them with your friends. (“I’ll give you a Fumo for a Leanne ‘I am The F$#ing Senator’ Washington”).

But it’s really the cynical and shady shenanigans like the Muhammad contretemps that, while legal, make our city stand out as a political cesspool. And it’s the shoulder-shrugging acceptance of such behavior that ensures that said cynicism and shadiness will continue.

Let’s define our terms. When I talk about “legal corruption,” I’m talking about dishonest or unethical behavior by those in positions of authority that is nonetheless within the bounds of the law. Let’s recap just a few other examples of our culture of legal corruption:

  • Councilmanic Prerogative, which is code for the handshake agreement that gives near-absolute power to each of our district City Council members over development projects on their turf. Remember how long it took for the Barnes to relocate to the city? That was, in part, because Councilwoman Jannie Blackwell blocked the relocation of the city’s Youth Detention Center to her West Philadelphia district for years—until she got a $12 million grant for a community center named after her late husband.
  • City Council’s Secret Budget. Each year, 15 separate city agencies appear before our august legislative body in order to justify their spending of taxpayer dollars. One such entity, as has long been customary, is exempt from such transparency: Council itself, which doesn’t subject its own $17 million to public scrutiny. If you search the city website real hard, you can find an unitemized budget; Council’s fiscal 2018 proposed appropriations includes a $1,904,485 line item for “Purchase of Services.” Presumably, that convenient pot of money is what enabled Council President Darrell Clarke to create a new position for his buddy, former Councilman Wilson Goode, Jr., after voters booted Goode from office in 2015. Suddenly, Goode was back in City Hall, as Clarke’s senior policy adviser, making $135,000 in taxpayer money—$6,000 more than he was taking in as a Councilman. That’s how Philly works—completely legal sweetheart deals between insiders with hardly any transparency and even less accountability.
  • “Nice Little Soda Business You Got There. It Would Be A Shame If Something Were To Happen To It.” It was perfectly legal when Mayor Kenney showed up to a meeting with soda bottler honcho Harold Honickman prior to the passage of the soda tax not with an officer of the city government—like Clarke—but, rather, with labor leader John Dougherty by his side. Honickman might have been forgiven had he inferred from Johnny Doc’s presence an ominous message, given what has proven to be Kenney’s modus operandi: Eschewing the finding of common ground in favor of Trump-like bullying.

It’s the cynical and shady shenanigans like the Muhammad contretemps that, while legal, make our city stand out as a political cesspool. And it’s the shoulder-shrugging acceptance of such behavior that ensures that said cynicism and shadiness will continue.

So why does L’affaire Muhammad qualify as legally corrupt? Well, it’s certainly dishonest. Seriously, Rodney Carpenter? And it smacks of the worst kind of cynicism, yet another example of a sophisticated perversion of progressivism orchestrated by the mayor.

Like many progressives, I was convinced by the studies that funding pre-K and rebuilding our parks and rec centers was smart, longterm economic development. That, during the mayoral campaign, candidate Kenney pledged to fund both efforts through innovative zero-based budgeting only made the policy seem even more groundbreaking.

Lo and behold, it’s going on two years since candidate Kenney interviewed for his job, and long gone is the innovative funding model; the soda tax is disproportionately harming the mayor’s own working class constituency; only 49 percent of the tax is actually funding local pre-K programs; and Council’s grubby Councilmanic Prerogative hands are already all over Rebuild, turning it into a cluster of giant proportions.

This is progressivism? Where are the voices meant to stand up for the average working class taxpayer? Oh, that’s right. Rodney Muhammad was supposed to be one of them.

The Philadelphia Citizen will only publish thoughtful, civil posts. We want to be a communal space. But that doesn’t mean you have a First Amendment right to be an idiot. Send us an insulting, offensive and/or wildly off-topic comment and not only will we refrain from posting it -- we will laugh at you before we hit delete.

Recent Tweets
@THEPHILACITIZEN

@thephilacitizen @@thephilacitizen
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
How was the Race + Public Space talk hosted by @UrbanConsulate along with @PlanPhilly and @knightfdn!? Tell us your… https://t.co/GrxKkTWsNz 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
"Sadly, too few Philadelphians have a steady household income of $40,000 to make this homeownership model work."… https://t.co/ZwFHAgzqYC 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
Wrap-up your holiday shopping at https://t.co/xfTQPPwgU2 and Amazon donates to Philadelphia Citizen. https://t.co/xfTQPPwgU2 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
Is an end to bullying in sight? @onwurd posed this question to its listeners. https://t.co/yZJlz9jJg4 #PHLed #EndBullying #OnWurd 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
"This stew of poverty, gentrification and government incentives is the crux of Philadelphia’s problems and the key… https://t.co/q6y7sXHfFH 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
Read @jongeeting's piece on the Philadelphia Parking Authority and then make sure to click the "Do Something" tab t… https://t.co/iANzb7TCUT 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
The Citizen's @dianamlind on the disparity between Philly's job market and housing market. https://t.co/8S0aHSSarM… https://t.co/XJDszzaXgR 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
#DoSomething by joining the fight for Philadelphia schools! Tomorrow's Philly Schools Town Hall is in the Northwest… https://t.co/T9mATwuCFX 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
From our weekly Do Something guide: a chance at discussion. Are our public spaces accessible to all? Join… https://t.co/mHeiSLD3gx 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
At a Letters To My Father workshop girls are encouraged to speak their truth without boundaries. Learn more about t… https://t.co/b91W2Uayry 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
Many in Puerto Rico are still without power including children and senior citizens. Here's how you can help.… https://t.co/qKdaCMWtGt 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
Citizen contributor and NBA legend Charles Barkley had more to say about last night's 4th quarter victory for Alaba… https://t.co/UHgS7d61HC 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
It's do or die for #NetNeutrality as many in the area join the planned protest in Washington tomorrow. Think this i… https://t.co/aUf5O9eghf 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
Philadelphia's real estate industry is booming but with a stagnant job-growth rate can anyone really afford a new h… https://t.co/kE3SJtyRHF 

LOAD MORE

Be a Citizen Editor

Suggest a Story