NEWSLETTER SIGNUP

By signing up to our newsletter, you agree to our terms.

Guest Commentary: Why Immigrants Are Good for the Economy

A high school econ teacher did the math. While there may be reasons to curb immigration—money isn’t one of them

A high school econ teacher did the math. While there may be reasons to curb immigration—money isn’t one of them

The Philadelphia Inquirer recently reported that Philadelphia arrests more noncriminal immigrants than any other city in the country. For some this news will be well received. Others will protest such a statistic, and both sides will invoke an array of standard arguments in defense of their positions.

One such category for arguments for the latter, however, can no longer be adequately proffered: economic arguments. A recent spate of news about the economic effects of immigration suggest that immigration is a net benefit on local economies. If one looks at Philadelphia they will see just these results.

Two economic arguments are commonly made against immigration. The first and most common argument is that non-legal immigrants take jobs away from American citizens. This claim, however, runs counter to a famous 1990 paper that found no effect on employment levels in Miami after the Mariel boatlift.

Prefer the audio version of this article? Listen to this story in CitizenCast below:

Recent research similarly finds that the immigration of high-skilled labor increases employment for native workers, while other research affirms that the hiring of immigrants increases productivity and exports by businesses, thereby maintaining domestic jobs.

The second economic argument against immigration derives from the first, but is usually proffered as a stand-alone argument: the wages effect. This latter argument asserts that a non-legal immigrant is likely to be hired over a citizen because the employer need not pay her a minimum wage. American citizens, facing competition from those lower-payed will ultimately need to accept lower wages than the labor market might otherwise offer.

Do Something

Yet just as before, the evidence is not supportive of such a position. As is reviewed by the Cato Institute and Noah Smith at Bloomberg View, there is no trade-off between immigration and wages; in fact, immigration may result in wage increases. Taken together, there is little macroeconomic justification for restricting immigration.

Philadelphia’s labor market experience with respect to immigration’s effect on wages and employment appears to bear this out. Several studies have highlighted Philadelphia’s immigration rates. For example, a Brookings Institution paper concluded that Philadelphia’s immigrants contributed 75 percent of the city’s growth in labor force participants between 2000 and 2007. Over the same period, we can see an overall increase in wages and a moderate increase in unemployment (attributable to cyclical unemployment) after the labor market recovers from the recession:

It is a similar story for more recent data. Between 2016 and 2017 the U.S. Census revealed that Philadelphia added to the amount of immigrants living here by 31 percent. Were the wages or jobs argument correct, we should see an increase in unemployment and decrease in wages. Once again, however, this is not borne out by the data, and instead the opposite occurs:

Simply put: immigrants help the local economy.

Read More

There are other arguments for and against immigration beyond that of economics. Though other research points to similar conclusions about the effect of immigration on communities (for example, immigrants have lower rates of law breaking, high rates of assimilation, and contribute more to social welfare programs than they receive back), an honest assessment of all arguments is assuredly necessary.

For immigration into America, and into a large city of brotherly love, gets to the heart of how we collectively define our shared identity. Nonetheless, let us countenance economic arguments against immigration no further: immigrants help the economy, and therefore help us all.

Justin Harbour teaches Advanced Placement economics at La Salle College High School. He lives in Mt. Airy with his wife and two children.

Photo: Frank Roche via Flickr

The Philadelphia Citizen will only publish thoughtful, civil posts. We want to be a communal space. But that doesn’t mean you have a First Amendment right to be an idiot. Send us an insulting, offensive and/or wildly off-topic comment and not only will we refrain from posting it -- we will laugh at you before we hit delete.

Recent Tweets
@THEPHILACITIZEN

thephilacitizen @thephilacitizen
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
#GuestCommentary | "From Boston-adelphia to Detroit-adelphia, we want all of Philadelphia to feel a can-do spirit i… https://t.co/i80snTWT1b 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
#Event ⚡️ Join us for an evening with Anand Giridharadas, author of the provocative new book, Winners Take All: The… https://t.co/ujmtztFufe 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
#GuestCommentary | "Detroit’s recovery...has been and continues to be a true team effort, a collaboration among the… https://t.co/Amq8GiU9AT 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
#DoSomething ⚡️ Visit Philly's magic gardens for an evening of relaxation and meditation among the art. More info h… https://t.co/gRMuKitBKO 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
#GuestCommentary | A trip to the Motor City leads The Economy League’s executive director to reflect on how far Phi… https://t.co/OwXGx0XysH 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
#CitizenCast | Listen to The Sanctuary Tragedy through our podcast: https://t.co/PqIBpYtyst 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
#TheCitizenRecommends | Have you seen @the_barnes collection yet? Get to know it through a fresh perspective with B… https://t.co/cB7ddiwAIK 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
#DoSomething ⚡️ Today is dedicated to island culture with the sounds of reggae, vendors selling authentic Caribbean… https://t.co/ShhTim2khV 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
Philly 3.0’s engagement director breaks down Pennsylvania’s surge in youth voter registration: https://t.co/tRR92H9UT5 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
The Value of the Abatement | The Philadelphia Citizen: https://t.co/d22ChP3TWv 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
As part of a series on the upcoming election, an urban demographer looks at how the state house races are likely to… https://t.co/ZgTRZqHwDL 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
By reacting to Trump like Trump, Mayor Kenney has shed more heat than light in the sanctuary debate. Maybe he shoul… https://t.co/PKq4XmyX77 

LOAD MORE

Be a Citizen Editor

Suggest a Story