NEWSLETTER SIGNUP

By signing up to our newsletter, you agree to our terms.

Do Something

Support independent journalism

In times like these, we need a free, independent news media more than ever. Help The Philadelphia Citizen stay strong by becoming a member today!

Connect WITH OUR SOCIAL ACTION TEAM



Cheat Sheet

The 30-second version of this story

  • President Trump has named the media as an enemy of the American people
  • He’s banned outlets from his press conferences, and his supporters are invoking Nazi-era language for the media
  • While this seems straight out of Richard Nixon’s playbook, it’s far worse; autocrats and dictators have used these tactics for decades to oppress their people
  • In particular, he is providing “alternative facts” to contest and delegitimize the news disseminated by trusted media mainstays like the New York Times
  • He’s even pressuring CNN to be more favorable, all while he considers their parent company’s proposed merger
  • In fact, this all reeks of Putin, who’s reduced his media to rubble
  • Preserving the First Amendment and getting the truth out will require reporters to not be cowed, to double down on deep reporting and accuracy, and, most important, to not take Trump’s bait and turn the relationship between the president and the press into a war of words

Election Apocalypse

How to fight back against Trump

Want to take action, but not sure how? Our Do Something guide is here to help.

Making the media into the “opposition party” comes from a familiar playbook

Presidents railing against the media is nothing new, of course. Richard Nixon called press outlets the “enemy,” while blackballing and intimidating reporters. But even Nixon had nothing on the current occupant of the White House, whose chief adviser, Stephen Bannon, has declared that the media is the “opposition party.”

The President has tweeted that the media are “the enemy of the people,” as he and his surrogates complain about “fake news” and assert their use of “alternative facts,” while his supporters complain about the Lugenpresse”—a Nazi-era slur meaning “lying press” in German. Turn on cable news and you can see that the battle lines have been drawn: Journalists are reluctant to believe anything emanating from the mouths of White House counselor Kellyanne Conway and press secretary Sean Spicer, given their penchant for regurgitating verifiable lies.   

Recently, things came to a head when the White House banned mainstream news outlets such as The New York Times, Washington Post, BBC, The Guardian and Politico from a press conference, allowing only conservative media organizations such as Breitbart News, The Washington Times and One America News Network.

Many have commented on Trump’s borrowing from Nixon’s media relations playbook, but I wondered whether the real influence behind Trump’s war on the press extends further back. That’s why I called Laura Henderson, a researcher at the University of Pennsylvania. Her work reveals the behavior patterns that link autocrats such as Vladimir Putin in Russia, Recep Tayyip Erdoğan in Turkey, and Viktor Orbán in Hungary, and it’s striking to consider Trump in terms of those examples.

“Another pattern within repressive regimes is support for explicit regime media, prioritized access and close ties,” says Laura Henderson at Penn. “Trump’s desire to legitimate and keep right wing publications such as Breitbart close to the administration seems to mirror the ‘autocratic playbook.’”

“With the rise of these right-wing governments, there is a clear move to restrict, silence, and punish critical voices and constrain independent media writ-large,” Henderson says.

According to Henderson, such censuring occurs in three distinct ways: “Laws and regulations, efforts to impact the economic vitality of critical media channels, and the proactive use of ideological forces—paid groups or trolls online as well as unpaid supporters—to flood information spaces with pro-regime propaganda and to delegitimate oppositional voices,” she says.

The Trump administration has focused particularly on the third strategy—providing “alternative facts” to contest and delegitimize the news disseminated by trusted media mainstays as The New York Times, CNN and the Washington Post. What sets Trump apart from the likes of Nixon and moves his conduct closer to the the likes of Putin is that he has gone beyond calling individual media outlets “the enemy” to categorizing the media in whole as “the enemy of the American People.”

“Another pattern within repressive regimes is support for explicit regime media, prioritized access and close ties,” Henderson adds. “Trump’s desire to legitimate and keep right wing publications such as Breitbart close to the administration seems to mirror the ‘autocratic playbook’ in this way.”

Also noteworthy is how the White House may attempt to pressure media conglomerates that refuse to toe the party line. A prime example is a recent meeting that Jared Kushner, Trump’s adviser and son-in-law, had with a top Time Warner Inc. executive. Kushner complained that CNN’s coverage is biased against Trump, and specifically singled out anti-Trump CNN contributors Ana Navarro, a Republican strategist, and Van Jones, a Democrat who served in the Obama administration. During his epic first press conference on February 16, the president attacked CNN numerous times—at a time when Trump reportedly is against approving the $85.4 billion of Time Warner to AT&T.

”These kinds of pressures need to be watched closely, because they can indicate more serious challenges to media independence,” Henderson warns.

What sets Trump apart from the likes of Nixon and moves his conduct closer to the the likes of Putin is that he has gone beyond calling individual media outlets “the enemy” to categorizing the media in whole as “the enemy of the American People.”  

As post-Soviet political expert Hannah Chapman noted in The Washington Post, Trump’s press conference eerily resembled those of Putin: “Access to the president is limited to circus-like news conferences attended primarily by regime supporters who ask the president softball questions,” she wrote. “The most recent of these conferences, held in December, included questions about stray animals, chess and kvass, a traditional drink made from fermented bread. One reporter even asked Putin how it felt to be ‘the most influential person in the world.’”

In Putin’s press conferences, hard-hitting professional reporters who are bound to challenge the leader are sidelined. Such political theater provides the illusion of a free press, all without government accountability and with few opportunities to express dissent.   

Both Putin and Trump understand that their press conferences are theater—and they master the stagecraft. Check out this report from a Russian journalist for a preview of what we’re in for from Trump for the next four years: “Facts don’t matter,” writes Alexey Kovalev. “You can’t hurt this man with facts or reason. He’ll always outmaneuver you. He’ll always wriggle out of whatever carefully crafted verbal trap you lay for him. Whatever he says, you won’t be able to challenge him. He always comes with a bag of meaningless factoids (Putin likes to drown questions he doesn’t like in dull, unverifiable stats, figures and percentages), platitudes, examples of false moral equivalence, and straight, undiluted bullshit. He knows it’s a one-way communication, not an interview.”

“Trump and his team have proved adept at changing the conversation, flooding information channels with commentary on a particular quote, tweet, or stunt,” Henderson notes. “It certainly moves the conversation away from any serious policy issues.”

Indeed, after a January Trump press appearance, Garry Kasparov, the former world chess champion and Putin critic, tweeted: “That reminded me of a Soviet press conference. More speakers than questions, more flags than answers.”

Welcome to the media landscape of the authoritarian strongman. Trump poses new challenges to journalists who hope to cover this administration and provide checks and balances to this most atypical president. Preserving the First Amendment and getting the truth out will require reporters to not be cowed, to double down on deep reporting and accuracy, and, most important, to not take Trump’s bait and turn the relationship between the president and the press into a war of words. The best way to hold authoritarian regimes accountable? Telling the truth.

Photo header: Flickr/Gage Skidmore

The Philadelphia Citizen will only publish thoughtful, civil posts. We want to be a communal space. But that doesn’t mean you have a First Amendment right to be an idiot. Send us an insulting, offensive and/or wildly off-topic comment and not only will we refrain from posting it -- we will laugh at you before we hit delete.

Recent Tweets
@THEPHILACITIZEN

@thephilacitizen @@thephilacitizen
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
One in five Philadelphians is at risk of going hungry every day. How *anonymous* food pantries can help: https://t.co/eJWSgWr9Qq 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
High school principal @selmekki reflects on what our immigrant and refugee students need most: https://t.co/dMpV6WyI6d 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
Series of forums works to strengthen relationship between local black youth and @PhillyPolice: https://t.co/1C4SlJhDqE 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
"The residents of Philadelphia don’t want people ripped out of their homes ... That hurts all of us.” https://t.co/YzHAN19wkQ 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
At our Citizen Speaks event, five university presidents discuss the role colleges play in shaping our city: https://t.co/D2iI21W7D0 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
READING LIST: Citizen writer @romney_jp publishes new book, "Printer's Error: Irreverent Stories from Book History." https://t.co/uQ04jOyK7A 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
.@XGames launches anti-bullying campaign, inspiring extreme sport athletes to take on all forms of harassment: https://t.co/NfcianTq9h 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
Today's special report on Sanctuary Cities is a long one. Here are some key facts to get you up to speed:… https://t.co/hT5G083aAb 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
If he doesn't step up, 2018 could be a repeat of the 2016 election—with Philly and PA the ultimate losers: https://t.co/tr9GN3IMV2 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
From The @guardian, Mexico City's deportee work program hopes to help ousted migrants resettle:… https://t.co/EX5LCQb2cP 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
To combat youth poverty rates, Nashville adopts program that connects teens and young adults with employers: https://t.co/gK78HFlrP1 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
.@irinnews writes about how women farmers are battling climate change in Zimbabwe: https://t.co/VS2t6zBXkF https://t.co/3BuvYbP2XT 
The Citizen
@thephilacitizen
RT @signsofsolidrty:PHILLY: Join us tomorrow for our #ArtOfTheProtest sign-making workshop with @MuralArts at the @KimmelCenter (FREE):… https://t.co/3blF2lUrL2 

LOAD MORE

Be a Citizen Editor

Suggest a Story